Are public sector workers ready for a wave of strikes?

Thursday’s strikes by public sector workers are due to go ahead after negotiations broke down yesterday. Civil servants and teachers will walk out in protest at the government’s proposal to reform their pensions. This one-day stoppage is being billed by public sector unions as a warm up for more widespread strikes in the autumn. Unison general secretary Dave Prentis has warned that Britain faces its biggest wave of industrial action since the general strike.

Whether the public sector unions have the power to cause such widespread disruption remains to be seen. They have been sabre-rattling for over a year now. We were promised a summer of discontent last year. This was followed by warnings of an autumn of discontent, a winter of discontent, a spring of discontent and now, well, here we are again.

If ballot turnout is anything to go by, support for the strikes is lukewarm. The PCS could only manage 61.1 percent of 32.4 percent. The teachers did a little better but still couldn’t get half of their members to vote. It could be that British workers have just got out of the habit of striking. According to the ONS, the number of days lost to labour disputes is at its lowest level since records began.

As Jane Dudman noted, there has been a change of mood among public sector managers over the last year.

The ironic thing is that in the past year the whole framework of the debate about public services and how they might be delivered in future has moved on incredibly fast.

Last week, the Guardian held a debate on rethinking public services, to discuss the challenge of new ways of running services. All the questions were about how this might be done. Not one single question or objection about whether it’s the right thing to do. That’s a quite remarkable shift in a short space of time among professionals who want to improve the services they deliver; imagine what the government could achieve if it took its managers with it, instead of alienating many of them.

I have noticed something similar, as have a number of friends and colleagues working in the public sector. If you’ll excuse the David Brentism, there is a feeling of we-are-where-we-are about all of this. Managers realise that public services can’t go on as they are for much longer. They can read the numbers and see the long-term forecasts. Most of them accept that far-reaching reform of the public sector will be necessary over the next few years. They may not like the way the government is going about it, they may think it is bonkers to cut so much during a recession and they may be incensed by the infantile pronouncements of some ministers but they recognise that the delivery of public services will need to be a lot cheaper by the end of this decade.

Admittedly, my data for this is anecdotal but the sense I get from talking to public servants is that, though the government’s plans are ham-fisted and lack coherence, much of what it is trying to do will have to be done sooner or later anyway. This has, to an extent, dissipated their anger. Some, like Mark Serwotka, still claim that no cuts or efficiency savings are necessary but for a growing number, the challenges facing the public sector don’t appear so clear-cut. This makes them less enthusiastic about taking industrial action against something many regard as, in some form, inevitable.

It remains to be seen whether the unions will be able to organise massive strike action in the autumn. The turnout on Thursday will give a clue about the strength of feeling. I may be proved wrong but I don’t sense much of an appetite for confrontation. The greatest danger to the government’s public sector reform programme may not be industrial action but its self-defeating assault on its own managers. As Jane Dudman says, by sacking many of them and pissing off the rest, the government has alienated the very people with the skills and knowledge to deliver the reforms.

Organisational change is extremely difficult to execute and the Coalition’s reform programme is the biggest public management challenge since the creation of the welfare state. Complex change programmes don’t need industrial action to make them fail; a simple lack of committed and capable managers will make failure a near certainty. There may not be a high turnout for srikes in the autumn but that doesn’t mean that the governent’s public sector reforms will be delivered smoothly. As any general knows, if you lose the support of your junior officers and NCOs, the battle is as good as lost.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Are public sector workers ready for a wave of strikes?

  1. Pingback: Are public sector workers ready for a wave of strikes? - Rick - Member Blogs - HR Blogs - HR Space from Personnel Today and Xpert HR

  2. We’ll see.
    I can buy the idea that many, many folk in public service – who are, let’s remember, now disproportionately white collar and think of themselves as being at least lower managerial/professional in status – have concerns about striking. Most of them, at least if they’re under 40, will never have been out on strike in their lives and will have treated their unions, if they are members, as a sort of workplace insurance policy.

    I can even buy the idea that, in their hearts, they don’t think there is much of an alternative because, well….let’s be frank, there isn’t one being articulated by the Labour Party is there? And all attempts to even suggest one might exist is being shouted down by the childish slogan of ‘deficit denier’. So, professionally speaking, they are liable to focus on the seeming inevitability of massive cuts.

    But… there is a widespread but inchoate sense of resentment. There has essentially been a three card trick played on the public. The crash of 2008 meant we spend a lot to rescue the banks, true, but perhaps more importantly it mean the whole hitherto operating ‘national business model’ based on an economy excessively dependent on the City and high finance (and thus awash with easy credit) was put into question. I’m not sure Humpty-Dumpty can ever be quite put back together again, as it were: the country needs to develop a new business model, not attempt to get back to the days of the ‘Great Moderation’.

    This has two key implications for the current conjecture: things:
    1. it is a radically uncertain matter as to whether the low tax regimes of the last 30 years can possibly continue – yet current politics operates as if this a ‘given’, a holy cow which can’t be touched ;
    2. The public sector did not create this problem. yet they are being blamed for it. Viciously. No attempt to being made to win their hearts and minds, to shore up any sense of public service ethos which is what drew most of them into the work they do in the first place. No: they are the slackers who are pulling the country down is the constant refrain from the press. Hence the deep resentment.

    You say,
    “As any general knows, if you lose the support of your junior officers and NCOs, the battle is as good as lost.” I’d go further in a military analogy; sometimes , in Vietnam and probably in all wars, if the troops don’t trust their officers they ‘frag’ them, intentionally, or just leave them to take unsupportable risks on their own. I don’t think we’re that far away from such a reaction in some parts of the public sector.

  3. Rick says:

    Charlie, my father and father-in-law told me of similar incidents in the British military – not outright sabotage but just leaving senior officers to hang themselves. Your NCOs, they told me, will make or break you.

    I agree that many public sector professionals are seriously angry about the way things have gone over the past year and, worse, the silly rhetoric that has gone with it. I think the anger among public sector managers will manifest itself in a lack support – as you say, not stopping ministers from taking unupportable risks and leaving them to fry when it all goes wrong.

  4. Pingback: The Biggest Public Sector Strike in Britain vis-a-vis the Rise of Turkey? « The Socio-Political Observer

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s